Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator: Which One is Better?

Magic Mill vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Dehydrating food is a great way to preserve it for long-term storage. This technique removes moisture, which prevents the growth of bacteria and other microorganisms that cause food to spoil. It also extends the shelf life of your food by reducing moisture content. Dehydrated food will keep for months or even years without spoiling. These foods are good sources of vitamins, minerals and other nutrients. They just take up less space so you can store more at one time.

If you have a lot of fresh produce available in your backyard or local farmers’ market, consider dehydrating some of it as an alternate means of preservation. You won’t use this machine every day, but when you need it, it’ll be there waiting for you!

If you are looking for an efficient food dehydrator, look no further as we compare Magic Mill vs Excalibur dehydrator side by side and find out which one is a better choice for your household. Here we go!

Magic Mill Vs Excalibur Dehydrator Comparison

FeaturesMagic Mill 7070 DehydratorExcalibur Dehydrator 3926TB
Dimensions15x13.5x19 Inches19x17x12.5 Inches
Weight16.70 lb22 lb
MaterialStainless Steel, PlasticStainless Steel, Plastic
Available ColorsStainless-Steel / BlackBlack
No. Of Trays7 Trays9 Trays
Tray Size13x12 Inch15x15 Inch
Total Drying Space7 Square Feet15 Square Feet
Temperature Range95-167F105-165F
Timer24 Hours26 Hours
Door StyleGlass Hinged DoorSolid Plastic Door / No Hinged
Wattage600W/110-120V440W/110-120V
Control PanelTouchscreenDials
Automatic Shut OffYesYes
Timer DisplayYesNo
AccessoriesMain Dehydrator UnitMain Dehydrator Unit
7 Drying Trays9 Dehydrating Trays
2 Mesh TraysFlexible poly-Screen Tray Inserts
2 Nonstick TraysRecipe Guide
2 GlovesUser Manual
Warranty Card
CleanupDishwasher Safe AccessoriesDishwasher Safe Accessories
Warranty1 Year Limited Warranty1 Year Limited Warranty
User Rating4.6/5 Star (3.5K Reviews)4.6/5 Star (3K Reviews)
Check Best PriceBuy on AmazonBuy on Amazon

Difference Between Magic Mill Vs Excalibur Dehydrator

Magic Mill MFD-7070 Vs Excalibur 3926TB are excellent food dehydrators that offer you ample space and excellent control to get the best results. The two dehydrators have a lot in common yet there are a number of differences that you might want to know before you consider either one of them. Let’s check out the key differences one by one in detail.

Appearance & Design

Magic Mill and Excalibur dehydrators have similar boxy design and it’s the placement of controls that makes the difference. Magic Mill food dehydrator features glossy stainless-steel exterior with black accents on the front and a transparent glass door to keep track of what’s happening in there.

The advanced control panel placed on the front side gives it a modern and premium touch. On the other hand, Excalibur 3926TB dehydrator features black exterior with a solid black removable door. Also, the controls are placed at the top right corner at the back which you may feel awkward while accessing.

Magic Mill dehydrator measures 15×13.5×19 Inches and weighs 16.70 lb whereas Excalibur dehydrator measures 19x17x12.5 inches and weighs about 22 pounds. Excalibur 3926TB is simply Bigger and heavier.  We like Magic Mill better in term of design and appearance!

Dehydrating Space

Dehydrating space is one of the major differences between the Magic mill and Excalibur 3926TB dehydrator. Magic Mill 7070 comes with 7 trays measuring 13×12 inches each and it offers a total space of 7 square feet. On the other hand, Excalibur dehydrator comes with 9 trays measuring 15×15 inches each with total space of 15 square feet which is twice the space of Magic Mill.

Sure, if you want to dehydrate large batches of fruits, veggies and other ingredients, Excalibur will be a more suitable choice however don’t rush, we have other differences that might change your mind.

Door style

As stated earlier, Magic Mill features a transparent glass door permanently connected via hinges while Excalibur dehydrator features a solid black door which is completely removable.

Time and Temperature

Magic Mill dehydrator can be programmed for about 24 hours and it features a temperature range of 95-167F while Excalibur dehydrator comes with a temperature range of 105-165F and it can be timed for 26 hours.

Another difference is the wattage: Magic Mill dehydrator 7070 is a 600W machine whereas Excalibur 3926TB is 440W dehydrator. Wattage do have an impact on the efficiency and performance while you dehydrate your favorite fruits.

Control Panel

Magic Mill dehydrator features an intuitive and modern touchscreen control panel with digital timer and temperature display where you can keep track of dehydrating cycle. The controls sit on the front side which is easily accessible and intuitive to use. Excalibur dehydrator 3926TB on the other hand features retro style knobs at the top right corner (back side) which is awkward to access. Also, Excalibur doesn’t have a digital display to let you know what temperature or time you have set so all you depend on is a timer knob and a thermostat.

Accessories

Magic Mill 7070 Dehydrator Accessories

  • Main Dehydrator Unit
  • 7 Drying Trays
  • 2 Mesh Trays
  • 2 Nonstick Trays
  • 2 Gloves 

Excalibur 3926TB Dehydrator Accessories

  • Main Dehydrator Unit
  • 9 Dehydrating Trays
  • Flexible poly-Screen Tray Inserts
  • Recipe Guide
  • User Manual
  • Warranty Card

What about cleanup? Cleaning accessories is as easy as it can get. Magic Mill and Excalibur dehydrator comes with dishwasher safe accessories, so just pop the accessories in your dishwasher and you are all set.

Dehydrating Performance

While testing and comparing two dehydrators, we noticed Magic Mill 7070 is more powerful and efficient in comparison to Excalibur 3926TB in terms of performance and speed. With more power, Magic Mill does the job somehow quicker than Excalibur 3926TB.

Magic Mill has got 4.6/5 star rating and 3.5K reviews on Amazon out of which 91% are satisfied with the performance. Excalibur 3926TB on the other hand got 4.6/5 star rating and 3K reviews out of which 91% are happy with the performance.

Another factor that will have huge impact on your purchasing decision is the Price. Magic Mill will cost you 1/3rd of what you will pay for Excalibur 3926TB. Of course Magic Mill comes with half the space in comparison to that of Excalibur but 360$ is too much to pay for some.

Quick Overview of Magic Mill Food Dehydrator Machine

Sale
Magic Mill Commercial Food Dehydrator Machine | 7 Stainless Steel Trays | Adjustable Timer,...
12,732 Reviews
Magic Mill Commercial Food Dehydrator Machine | 7 Stainless Steel Trays | Adjustable Timer,...
  • REAR MOUNT FAN FOR SUPERIOR HEAT DISTRIBUTION – DRIES FOOD EVENLY The electric dehydration machine is equipped with a rear-mounted drying fan and air flow circulation technology to promote even drying, there is no need to rotate the shelves as needed by other brands, monitor the dryer process easily with the transparent door window
  • DIGITAL THERMOSTAT AND TIMER- AUTOMATIC SHUT OFF WHEN TIMER DONE -- An adjustable temperature and timer ensure you to have your delicious, dehydrated food done to perfect at optimal temperature and exact timing; the Countdown timer will show you when it will be done, once done it will automatically shut off

The Good √

  • Contemporary design
  • Touchscreen controls, digital timer
  • 7 dehydrating trays measuring 13×12 Inch each
  • Use for fruits, veggies, meat, beef, dog treats, and more
  • Dishwasher safe accessories
  • Even heat distribution for incredible performance
  • Overheat protection, auto shut off features
  • Budget friendly price tag

The Bad ×

  • Gives off slightly burnt plastic smell for first time
  • Learning curve

Quick Overview of Excalibur Food Dehydrator

Sale
Excalibur 3926TB Electric Food Dehydrator Machine with 26-Hour Timer, Automatic Shut Off and...
3,319 Reviews
Excalibur 3926TB Electric Food Dehydrator Machine with 26-Hour Timer, Automatic Shut Off and...
  • Large Capacity: Equipped with 9 Excalibur dehydrator trays, this large food dehydrator boasts 15 square feet of drying space
  • Versatile Uses: Features a 26-hour dehydrator timer and an adjustable thermostat with a range of 105 to 165 degrees F – low enough for fruits and vegetables but high enough for dehydrating meat

The Good √

  • Large dehydrating space of 15 Square feet
  • 9 trays measuring 15×15 Inch each
  • Dishwasher safe trays and other accessories
  • Automatic and efficient
  • Multiple handy accessories
  • 26 hour timer

The Bad ×

  • Very expensive
  • Large footprint
  • Hard to accommodate in small kitchen spaces
  • Controls located at the back are awkward to access

Magic Mill Vs Excalibur Dehydrator: Which One’s Better?

Now that we have checked almost every single detail about the two dehydrators, it would be easy to figure out who is the winner of Magic Mill vs Excalibur dehydrator contest. Not yet? Here is an easy clue!

Magic Mill has well designed and easy to follow touchscreen control panel, beautiful design, digital timer, and compact design in comparison to Excalibur 3926TB which doesn’t have digital timer, controls are awkwardly placed and its huge and expensive.

So, if you don’t want a monster of machine on your counter, sleek and stylish Magic Mill with a budget friendly tag is just the right choice. But if you can spare extra bucks, go ahead with Excalibur which in return will provide you with huge dehydrating capacity.

We are rooting for Magic Mill 7070 dehydrator, what are going to choose and why? Tell us about your experience with your first ever food dehydrator in the comment section down below!

How long does dehydrated food last?

Dehydrated food can last anywhere from several months to several years, depending on the type of food and the storage conditions. Properly dehydrated and stored foods can retain their quality, flavor, and nutrition for an extended period.

Generally, fruits and vegetables can last up to 12 months when properly dehydrated and stored in airtight containers in a cool, dry place. Jerky can last up to 2 years when vacuum-sealed and stored in a cool, dry place.

However, factors such as humidity, temperature, and exposure to light can affect the shelf life of dehydrated food. Moisture is the biggest enemy of dehydrated food, as it can cause mold and spoilage. Therefore, it is essential to store dehydrated food in airtight containers in a cool, dry place away from sunlight.

It is also recommended to label the containers with the date of dehydration to keep track of the freshness of the food. In summary, with proper dehydration and storage, dehydrated food can last for an extended period, making it an excellent option for food preservation and convenience.

About the author

Claire Bella

Claire Bella is an American food blogger and recipe developer. She has also contributed to several other blogs, including Serious Eats, The Kitchn, and food52. Claire recipes have been featured in publications such as Bon Appétit, The New York Times, and Martha Stewart Living.